The subject was a favourite of the Munich school painters, yet Lentz’s version is far removed from the sentimental imagery of Stanisław Witkiewicz’s shepherdess or even Józef Chełmoński’s Indian Summer (Babie lato), once scandalous for the girl’s ostentatiously dirty feet. Though painterly less refined than those two, Lentz’s portrait strikes a powerful chord through its raw immediacy. The boy’s torn, grimy clothes are one thing; his sad, distrustful gaze tells of the poverty and harshness of peasant life as forcefully as many written pages of social history. In Fryderyk Pautsch’s Fiddler – Symbolic Scene Against Landscape (Skrzypek – scena symboliczna na tle pejzażu), by contrast, the departure from idyllic fantasy leads in the opposite direction: against the backdrop of the artist’s more conventional Hutsul scenes, the painting stands out through its Munch-like stylization, compositionally close to the Norwegian’s Anxiety painted fifteen years earlier. Here the femme fatale of Young Poland takes the form of a Hutsul girl, who, despite the misogynistic cliché, asserts a presence and subjecthood absent from the usual rustic idealizations.
While rooted in the realities of partition-era struggles for identity, the Lausanne exhibition does not weave sweeping narratives of national art. Instead, it introduces subtle shifts of emphasis, enabling familiar works to be seen in a new setting that is formally and thematically aligned with Swiss (and broader European) 19th-century upheavals and revaluations. It shows, in passing, that, despite the political circumstances, this truly was a ‘happy hour’ for Polish painting and that, however overexposed Young Poland may seem, it still rewards a fresh gaze.