It seems perfectly valid to say that Dumała would be different – interesting, but one of many – had he not started to use the plaster panel technique. Indeed, some of his films may not have been made, and it would have been difficult for him to make his drawn characters look alive, realistic and able to experience emotions as well as – and this is particularly evident in Zbrodnia i kara – to make them unique and expressive and seem to have their own internal lives and individual, distinguishing traits. This was pointed out by Małgorzata Karbowiak when she wrote about Łagodna, Dumała’s second film made with the use of engraving on plaster, hailed by the critics his first masterpiece to have demonstrated the full strengths of this unique technique of his. Karbowiak writes:
An astonishingly difficult task has been accomplished: that of showing two people who, while living side by side, cannot establish mutual contact, and at the same time of giving it a universal appeal – the task of making a philosophical as well as psychological film. Philosophy is much easier to achieve in animated cinema; psychology comes much harder.
This is what Dumała, who according to Karbowiak has found ‘a technique which perfectly serves the purpose’, said in an interview with Krzysztof Biedrzycki (Film 16/1986):
I wanted to try to make an animated psychological film. Animated films are supposed to be either fun or sublime artistic visions. I wanted to enter the human mind, to prove that animation is suitable for presenting the most central human issues.
Marcin Giżycki, in turn, wrote (Nie tylko Disney...):
The full potential of plaster boards was demonstrated ... by the two films after Dostoevsky, ‘Łagodna’ and ‘Zbrodnia i kara’. Today these works are hard to imagine made using some other technique. The thick drawing and texture and the extraordinary fluidity of animation achieved through the transformation of a starting picture instead of replacing it with another the way classical cartoons do can only be compared with the effects obtained by Alexandre Alexeieff and Claire Parker with the use of another unique technique, the pinscreen. ... The plaster technique has proven particularly suitable for bringing to daylight the huge spiders and other phantoms from the characters’ souls.
Old Masters
Watching Dumała’s films we seem to commune with the great masters of European painting, a feeling which is confirmed by him when interviewed by Krzysztof Biedrzycki (Film 16/1986):
lLatające włosyl and lŁagodnal were made, besides myself, by Munch, Rembrandt, Vermeer, Redon, Daumier.”
And this is another strength of Dumała’s animations made using plasterboards – that is, of most of his works. He approaches them the way the old masters did, covering the boards with a layer of paint to provide the background. Baroque inspirations are particularly noticeable (Latające włosy, Łagodna), shades of brown, white and black dominating and other colours seldom used (Zbrodnia i kara). When writing about Łagodna (Kino 10/1986), Krzysztof Biedrzycki is right to observe that the blacks and browns ‘create an atmosphere of hopelessness, of the two characters being trapped’, while the red wine in a glass and the red of the woman’s dress are like a scream. And there is a real scream in Łagodna: at one point the woman’s face becomes shaped like the face from Edvard Munch’s famous painting, which is a strikingly literal device.
There are more such references to works by and quotations from old masters in Dumała’s animations, and they provide extra meanings as well as introducing clear cultural signs, a trick which attracts the viewers’ attention, a sophisticated post-modernist game which the artist fully controls. Jacek Dobrowolski has called Dumała ‘a spiritual cousin of the Quay Brothers (...) the magicians of the avant-garde animated filmmaking’. Like they, he too
traverses the stormy waters of liberated imagination which were earlier sailed across by other visionary symbolists: Goya and Max Ernst, Odilon Redon, Daniel Mróz, Edward Gorey, Jonathan Swift, Kafka, Borges and Edgar Allan Poe.
The world he creates, however, is his very own:
It is a kingdom of night and darkness, dreams and shadows, where silhouettes emerge from the dark and stay in semi-darkness, never appearing in bright daylight (...) It is the world of a child amazed with the beauty and cruelty of the World (Kino 6/2002).
This is what Dumała says about it in an interview with Małgorzata Pawłowska-Tomaszek (Kwartalnik Filmowy 19-20/1997):
What interests me in filmmaking is the penetration of the ‘ultimate mystery’, that is of what we do not understand, what has got no name. It is God for some, fate for some, and for others it is the reason for the existence of the world or the question who we are and why we exist, or what drives what we do. We live to approach this mystery – everyone in their own way.
Dumała’s engraving on plaster technique, which has been successful also in his commercial assignments, and the superior artistic effect achieved in Zbrodnia i kara have been a challenge to which he has since responded with Las and John D., an animation on John Doe, a sixteenth-century English magician and scholar. Both films use a combined acting-and-drawing technique.
His first feature was Las / The Forest, which combined the technique of animation with cinematography by Adam Sikora. The main roles of father and son were played by Stanisław Brudny and Mariusz Bonaszewski. In 2009 it was shown in the main competition of the Polish Film Festival in Gdynia, where it was awarded with a special prize for artistic merit, as well as in the competition of the Era New Horizons film festival in Wrocław. It was also nominated for four Orzeł awards. Tadeusz Sobolewski wrote in Gazeta Wyborcza:
I’ve watched ‘The Forest’. It is a perfect, pure, fulfilled film. Something very rare. An organic piece of art, which stands on its own. Simple, minimalistic, hypnotizing. Mysterious as a dream (...) This film is filled with something long forgotten in Polish cinema, something characteristic of Has’s films. Cinema is truly personal not when it gives us the director’s intimate experience, but when it says something important about me as a viewer, something, that makes me ask: ‘how did he know that?‘
Dumała is the protagonist of Joanna Dylewska’s documentary Świat według Piotra D. / The World According to Piotr D. (2001). The first Polish screening of his latest feature, Ederly, will take place at the T-Mobile New Horizons film festival in July 2016.
Filmography
Film etudes:
- 1976 – Przemiana / The Metamporphosis
- 1977 – Śmierć Hindenburga / Hindenburgh’s Death
- 1980 – Scenka rodzajowa / A Genre Scene
Animated films:
- 1981 – Lykantropia / Lycantrophy; combined technique; black humour. A story of werewolves who prove to be people turned into beasts. Based on a grotesque idea: a pack of hungry wolves is waiting for a tasty morsel – a man. Suddenly one of them drops the wolf’s skin, revealing he is a man. This is his undoing – he is eaten by his companions. Other wolves do the same one by one and each one meets the same fate” (Krzysztof Biedrzycki, Kino 10/1986). Awards: 1986 – Stanisław Wyspiański Award at the Lubuskie Lato Filmowe in Łagów, together with Łagodna and Latające włosy.
- 1983 – Czarny Kapturek/ Little Black Riding Hood; cartoon. Black humour. An alternative version of the popular fairytale. The Black Riding Hood boy is a black character who devours the wolf. The wolf then eats up the hunter who, however, gets out from its stomach. The end is less bloody and fantastic and more human. The wolf discovers a naked woman in bed and throws himself on her, demonstrating his ‘male organ’ to the audience. “The success of the film is built on the way it was drawn. Dumała contrasts his ‘black’ version of the fairytale with extremely simple, almost childlike drawing. This clash between the pictures and the content is the key source of humour” (Marcin Giżycki, Nie tylko Disney: rzecz o filmie animowanym, Warsaw 2000). Awards: 1983 – 2nd Award in the 5 to 10 minute category at the 3rd International Animated Film Festival in Varna; 1984 – honorary mention at the 12th International Huesca Film Festival.
- 1984 - Latające włosy / Flying Hair. A poetic, impressionistic work about a girl and a boy in love with each other who go out for a walk. Suddenly a storm breaks out. The girl’s hair turns into sharp needles which fly around attacking and destroying everything. Only the couple are safe. Dumała’s first film using his own technique of engraving in plaster to produce fascinating artistic effects and flowing movements. “It is a symbolic film. All of it is a symbol. It acts on the subconscious” (Film 16/1986, Krzysztof Biedrzycki’s interview). “It is not a perverse fairytale, it is a poetic tale of the redeeming power of love” (Krzysztof Biedrzycki, Kino 10/1986). Awards: 1984 – Artistic Merit Award at 24th National Short Film Festival in Cracow; 1986 – Stanisław Wyspiański Award at the Lubuskie Lato Filmowe in Łagów, together with Łagodna and Lykantropia.
- 1985 – Łagodna / The Gentle One. A free adaptation of Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s short story by the same title. A study of jealousy, love, hatred and alienation of two people, a young woman and an older man. Dumała’s first psychological film in which his plaster board technique proved highly successful. Janusz Zaremba wrote (Ekran 25/1985) that Dumała achieved “a very evocative artistic equivalent for Dostoyevsky’s short story”. “His ‘Łagodna’ ... is made of chiaroscuro, dark sepia images with a single source of light, producing the impression that Rembrandt’s etchings have come alive” (Jacek Dobrowolski, Kino 6/2002). Zygmunt Konieczny’s moving music accompanies the characters’ retrospections. “Łagodna is one of the most interesting achievements of Polish animation. It is a gripping film – and a wise one, too” (Krzysztof Biedrzycki, Kino 10/1986). Awards: 1985 – Cinematography President Animated Film Award for photography; Brązowy Lajkonik at 5th National Short Film Festival in Cracow; Golden Dragon Grand Prix Award at 12th International Short Film Festival in Cracow, 1st Prize at 3rd National Animated Film Competition in Cracow; Golden Ducat at 34th International Film Festival in Mannheim; Best Animated Film Award at International Short Film Festival in Tours; Silver Dancer Animated Film Award at 13th International Short Film Festival in Huesca; 1986 – Special Prize in the 5 to 15 minute category at International Animated Film Festival in Hamilton, Canada; 1st Prize at the Lubuskie Lato Filmowe in Łagów; Stanisław Wyspiański Young Artist Award, together with Latające włosy and Lykantropia; 1987 – Award of 2nd ANIMAFILM Animated Film Festival in Zamość.
- 1986 – Nerwowe życie kosmosu. Black humour. A strange world, populated by characters from frightening fairytales, somewhere in the universe. Awards: 1987 – Honorary Diploma at 24th International Short Film Festival, Cracow.
- 1986 – Academy Leader Variations (dir. David Ehrlich), sequence of an American film made collectively by artists from Poland, USA, China and Switzerland. Awards: 1987 – Animation Award at 40th Cannes International Film Festival.
- 1987 – Ściany / Walls. A story of a man locked in a room without an exit and failing to find a way out. Someone drops in a coin through a hole and switches off the bulb. A study of claustrophobia and a gloomy parable interpreted as an allusion to the situation of Poles living within the confines of a communist country. A metaphor of a society living in a totalitarian system. With evocative music by Przemysław Gintrowski. Awards: 1988 – 5 to 10 Minutes Best Film Award at Espinho International Animated Film Festival; mention at Oberhausen International Short Film Festival; 2nd Prize at Mottawa International Animated Film Festival; Spanish Federation of Film Debating Clubs and Silver Dancer for the Best Animated Film at Huesca International Short Film Festival; Golden Dragon Grand Prix at the Cracow 25th International Short Film Festival; Grand Prix at 2nd Animated Film Festival in Zamość; Special Prize at the Annecy International Animated Film Festival; 1989 – Grand Prix for a 5+ Minute Film for Adults at Animated Film Biennial Fazy ‘89.
- 1988 – Wolność nogi / Freedom of the Leg. A dream-like story of a sleeping man whose body parts live their own lives at night to return to him in the morning – all except one leg which has chosen freedom. Its owner as well as a crowd of homeless men chase the leg, but it grows feathers and flies away as a bird. A grotesque tale with a poetic ending and with interesting music by Janusz Hajdun. Awards: 1989 – Grand Prix at 1st Animated Film Biennial FAZY’89 in Bielsko-Biała; Brązowy Lajkonik at 19th National Short Film Festival in Cracow; Professional Prize at the Kiev KROK Festival; 1990 – 1st Prize for a 5 to12 Minute Film at the Zagreb World Festival of Animated Films.
- 1988 – Declaration Of Human Rights, sequence of a film made for Amnesty International,
USA.
- 1990 – Horse – made for MTV.
- 1991 – Franz Kafka. A film about a few years from Kafka’s life, based mostly on his Diaries. “Their language, more chaotic and direct, differs from that of the novels – it is expressive, vivid, often crude, but more than anything very detailed and good at conveying the sensuality of the world. It is Kafka whom we do not know from his short stories or aphorisms – one who loves immersing himself in corporality, in people’s physiognomies and smells, in the pathological details of their bodies and dress, and in his own, grotesquely enlarged thinness and his body’s proneness to illness ... Here is not the author of well-known novels, but, first of all, a man” (Barbara Kosecka, “Kwartalnik Filmowy”, 19-20/1997). Barbara Kosecka’s praise for the film: “ Franz Kafka, a sixteen-minute masterpiece of animation” (Kino 2/2002). Awards: 1992 – Polish Filmmakers Association Award for the Best 1990-1991 Animation; Bronze Dragon for Animated Film and International Federation of Film Clubs (FICC) Don Kichote Award at 39th Cracow ISFF; Grand Prix at the Zagreb World Festival of Animated Films; Grand Prix at IAFF in Espinho, Portugal; First Prize for the Best Animated Film and the title of Europe’s Best 1991-1992 Animated Film at IFF in Madrid; 1st Prize in the 15-30 minute film category at 4th Animated IFF in Hiroshima; Special Mention at IAFF in Stuttgart; The Young Award for Best Animated Film at ISFF at Oberhausen; Best Drawn Animation Award at International Animation Festival in Ottawa; 1993 – 3rd Prize for the Most Original Film at 10th Odensee IFF; 1st Film Poster Prize at the Annecy IFF.
- 1993 – Nerwowe życie I. A series of twenty-one fifteen-second-long cartoon jokes made for the Łódź Television Centre and including Śniadanie, Mucha, Fryzjer, Ikar, Palec, Ketchup, Zeppelin, Sąsiadki, Papieros, Odwiedziny, Cień, Kapturek and others.
- 1993 – Charlatan – made for MTV. Awards: 1994 – Golden Statuette of the Broadcast Design Festival in Orlando, Florida; finalist of 36th New York Festival.
- 1993 – MTV is everywhere – made for MTV. Awards: 1994 – Silver Statuette of the Broadcast Design Festival in Orlando, Florida.
- 1994 – Nerwowe życie II – three-part animated TV series. Awards: 1994 – Premio Mister Linea at the Treviso Festival.
- 1994 – Stop Aids – three-part series, 10 seconds each. Awards: 1994 – joint first prize in Slovenia.
- 1995 – Wieje piaskiem od strony wojny – video-clip for the group Maanam.
- 1995 – Kafka meets Dostoyevski. Awards: 1996 – Broadcast Design International, Los Angeles, Gold Award.
- 1996 – Absolut Panushka – 10-second sequence for the US film. Awards: 1996 – Best Animated Campaign at the Holland Animation Film Festival, Utrecht; 1997 – Best Animation Produced for Internet at the World Animation Celebration in Pasadena, California.
- 1997 – 14 Bajek z królestwa Lailonii – trailer of the series. After a book by Leszek Kołakowski. Each film was made by a different director.
- 2000 – Zbrodnia i kara / Crime and Punishment. Adaptation of the homonymous novel by Fyodor Dostoevsky. Thirty-four minutes’ long, no dialogues, with music by Janusz Hajdun. “My film is a kind of a dream. It is as if someone has read ‘Crime and Punishment’ and then had a dream about it” (Gazeta Wyborcza, 29 August 2997, interview by Katarzyna Bielas). Jacek Dobrowolski (Kino 6/2002) wrote: “ Crime and Punishment is Piotr Dumała’s opus magnum. His mastery in conveying the truth about the human mind is worthy of Bergman’s. Although not a single word is said, the perfect narration makes the plot, the states of the killer’s mind and St Petersburg’s scenery into a unity, and the simplest objects, such as a watch or an axe, speak for themselves as well as for Raskolnikov. The result is an accurate account of the states of the killer’s mind and a psychological portrait as penetrating as the one which Dostoevsky made with words.” Awards: 2000 – Złota Kreska at National Animated Film Festival in Cracow; 2001 – Korona Króla Kazimierza Animated Film Audience Award at Lato Filmowe in Kazimierz Dolny; Grand Prix at 2nd Biesiada z Filmem Krótkiego Metrażu DAF in Szczecin.
- 2009 – Walka, miłość i praca / Fight, love and work. First work by Dumała in the public space, outside of cinema and gallery. The inspiration was a piece by a Romanian composer Alexander Balanescu, entitled Lullaby Dream.
- 2009 – Las / The Forest. A black and white experimental film. It takes place in two space-time continnums. An elderly man leads his son through the woods, and at the same time he lies in his death bed. The film tries to capture the liminal stage between life and death. It explores the difficult relationship between father and son. Animation is connected on an equal level with scenes played by actors. The formal idea consists in a smooth editing of these two interwining worlds, so that the viewer doesn’t really notice the change, but sees the homogenous language of the story (...) The subject of both stories is the relationship between a very old man and a middle-aged one. It is a correlation where domination, collaboration, love and death come into play. The story about two men in the woods is a reference to the biblical story of Abraham and Isaac.
- 2010 – Dr Charakter Przedstawia / Dr Charakter Presents. A pastiche of old scientific TV shows and an ironic commentary about the domination of different peculiarities in television. The title character in his show presents original scientistc, inventors and a gallery of curiosities. Legendary Polish film critic Jerzy Płażewski is the voice of Dr Charakter.
- 2012 – Kołysanka / Lullaby. Animated short. A dream-like flight above surreal landsacpes to the tune of Krzysztof Komeda’s famous lullaby.
- 2012 – Dr Charakter Przedstawia 2/ Dr Charakter Presents II
- 2014 – Hipopotamy / Hippos. Seven young, naked women take a bath with their children in a river flowing through a forest. It’s idyllic. A group of five naked men wathces them, hidden in the bushes. They are excited. One of them decides to act, but the woman turns him down. The male falls into the water, raising laughter among his friends. Angry, he stands up and tries to take her by force.
- 2016 – Ederly (in production). Ederly is a city outside of time, on the border between reality and dream. It might seem that it exists only for the main protagonist – Slow – to come there. When he arrives, new identities are forced upon him. The film might be described as a surreal comedy with a hint of crime or as a philosophical essay on life. The magical plot is accompanied by a realist visual side and black-and-white cinematography is a reference to silent cinema. Main roles are played by Mariusz Bonaszewski and Gabriela Muskała.
Author: Jan Strękowski, July 2004, updated by NMR, June 2016.