Saving universality
And this is also where the exhibition’s most interesting, and undoubtedly most central question arises – the question about the possibility of a universal imagination. The belief in the universality of the categories with which we describe the world has been, after all, largely irretrievably compromised. It is in dislocated Enlightenment ideals about universal humanity, rights and duties, already marked by racism and chauvinism at their very foundations, that cultural scientists can often find sources of colonial violence and the brutality of the 20th century’s wars, the shadows of which still haunt a Europe often unwilling to come to terms with its heritage.
Nevertheless, as historian Susan Buck-Morss convincingly described in her analysis of the Haitian revolution, a certain layer of universal experience is worth saving – namely that which, in moments of strain, dehumanisation and humiliation, offers hope for emancipation and the recovery of basic dignity. Believing in universals here does not mean equating all experiences and ignoring their specificity – on the contrary, it expresses hope in the universal desire for self-determination, in the strength of the weaker and the more vulnerable.
Mikołaj Sobczak, "Mantis", 2020, photo: courtesy of the artist and the Servais Family Collection
The most ambitious works in the exhibition drawing on such a renewed belief in the universality of emancipatory aspirations, are the paintings – or rather, due to their experimental technique and materials, pictorial works – by Mikołaj Sobczak. His works explore queer genealogies, histories of oppression, and moments of transition and transformation in order to show how thinking about the past can be a laboratory for constructing the future. By freely combining themes from different cultures and times – the persecution of sexual minorities by the Stasi, the oppression of Ukrainian peasants by Polish landowners, the destruction of the house and works of the painter Polina Rajko by the Russians, and the first ever LGBTQ+ uprising at Compton’s Cafeteria – Sobczak allows us to think of history not so much as a sequence of inevitable successive events, but rather as an area of infinite potentiality, in which untapped forces and resources, possible scenarios, alternatives to what we have learned to see as inevitable, lie dormant all the time. The artist does acknowledge the uniqueness of historical phenomena though – this can be seen, for example, in the different techniques with which he represents individual events: combining prints and photographs in Zniewolenie [Captivity]; near-abstract painterly daubings with precise drawing in Pogrzeb [Burial]; or combining rich colour with sparing black and white in the fist-shaped painting Diana and Actaeon. He also suggests that universal ‘rescue stories’ are possible too in a world marked by imperial universalism.
Mikołaj Sobczak, "Funeral", 2022, fot. dzięki uprzejmości artysty